3-2-1] If you can't defend it, don't send it


Hey Reader,

Welcome to the 30th edition of the 3-2-1 (check out previous issues here).

One idea from me first, three links that go deeper on it, then two things that have nothing to do with work. Let's get into it.


1 Idea from Me

If you can't defend it, don't send it

This week PwC said it will spend > $100 million to put 85,000 people through a new Critical Thinking & Judgment Certificate.

All four of the Big Four have been called out this year for client reports and research full of AI-made citations. But PwC's stated reason is more interesting. Its chief people and inclusion officer said that as AI takes on foundational tasks, "some of the repetition that really helped our people to develop critical thinking and judgment just won't be there."

When I first saw the news, I thought it was quite silly. A certificate is a snapshot, and critical thinking is something you have to keep doing.

Then I dug into the program. It's mostly practice: a thinking-style diagnostic, realistic simulations, an AI coach, and an assessment at year-end. That's the right approach. Daniel Willingham's research (third link below) says people can't apply thinking advice they've memorized without practice and knowledge of the domain.

I'm hearing a version of this from clients. They spent the last two years getting people to use AI. Now they're living with what it produces. A director at a large tech company put it to me this way:

"I'm finding myself increasingly overwhelmed with... AI slop. It masks itself as [a recommendation], and then I have to spend time sifting through that to see if the work was done."

That's cognitive surrender. I say a version of this to my own team all the time: if you can't defend it, don't send it.

I've been reading the Dune books. Frank Herbert saw this coming in 1965:

"Once men turned their thinking over to machines in the hope that this would set them free. But that only permitted other men with machines to enslave them."

In his story, people didn't just ban the thinking machines after the war against them. They built schools to train human minds to do that thinking again. That's PwC's bet.

It's ours too. We built our Seek-Sense-Ship framework with tech companies that adopted AI early. Today I want to use it to answer the question that seems to be on everyone's mind:

How do we help people use AI to produce better work without outsourcing their judgment?

Here are 12 principles for answering this question:

Read the 12 principles β†’


3 Things for Work (in L&D)

Your Brain on ChatGPT (Kosmyna and colleagues, MIT Media Lab, Jun 2025)

  • 54 people wrote essays with ChatGPT, with a search engine, or with nothing. Brain scans showed the ChatGPT group had the weakest brain connectivity, and many couldn't accurately quote the essay they had just written.
  • πŸ‹ Effort β‰ˆ 3 min for the abstract (the full paper is long)

To Trust or to Think (BuΓ§inca, Malaya and Gajos, 2021)

  • 199 people made decisions with help from an AI. Designs that made them think before accepting its suggestion cut overreliance, but people liked that user experience the least. That's why cognitive surrender is so easy.
  • πŸ‹ Effort β‰ˆ 3 min for the abstract

Critical Thinking: Why Is It So Hard to Teach? (Daniel Willingham, Arts Education Policy Review, 2008)

  • Written for teachers, and it applies to every corporate training program. Willingham's case is that critical thinking "is not a skill" you learn once and use anywhere. It depends on domain knowledge and practice. Read it before you buy a critical thinking course.
  • πŸ‹ Effort β‰ˆ 25 min read (13 pages)

2 Things for Life

Lessons from meditating for 20+ years (a letter to my niece)

  • My niece is heading to a spiritual retreat, and her parents asked us to write her a letter. I anonymized it and posted it here in case it's useful to you too.
  • πŸ‹ Effort β‰ˆ 2 min read

A GIF about not giving up (@andresyoutubee on X)

  • A short GIF about perseverance. I showed it to my 6-year-old and he said he wanted to be like the guy in the bottom frame.
  • πŸ‹ Effort β‰ˆ 30 seconds

That's it for this week - enjoy your Sunday!

I'll be back in two weeks ✌️

Andrew

P.S. πŸ‘‰ If your team is sending you work that looks finished and isn't, that's the problem we work on. We teach people a process for judgment on their real work, with AI in it. Hit reply and tell me what you're seeing.

Andrew Barry

ICs can do more on their own with AI than ever before. This is both a challenge and an opportunity for L&D. This newsletter explores how to equip ICs with the influence skills that drive retention, accelerate OKRs, and position L&D as a strategic partner to the business. (Sent twice a month).

Read more from Andrew Barry
A bear steers a ship’s wheel atop a ladder as a cat and dog pass a red folder upward, while a lion and colleague draw a yellow arrow on a workbench plan, contrasting distant leadership with hands-on problem-solving.

Hey Reader, Welcome to the 29th edition of the 3-2-1 (check out previous issues here). One idea from me first, three links that go deeper on it, then two things that have nothing to do with work. Let's get into it. 1 Idea from Me You can't steer a living company from the top Almost every company's success is tied to how well they embrace AI in their products and the way they work. Since things are moving so quickly, speed is critical. That means the speed of decision-making, and specifically...

Three suited animals toss speech bubbles that fall short of a stairwell landing, while a young cat delivers a signed yellow document to a lion already reviewing it, illustrating the shift from opinions to decisions

Hey Reader, Welcome to the 28th edition of the 3-2-1 (check out previous issues here). One idea from me first, three links that go deeper on it, then two things that have nothing to do with work. Let's get into it. 1 Idea from Me Opinions are free. Recommendations cost something. "Heads up, customer complaints about onboarding are up." Then the Slack thread goes quiet (a thumbs-up emoji appears), and the problem is yours now. If you lead a team, you know what I mean. What you want is what I...

Three suited animals cheer around a giant calculator reading 31 R 12 while four travelers stand stranded at the curb, and a lion in a blazer waves in one more yellow bus.

Hey Reader, Welcome to the 27th edition of the 3-2-1 (check out previous issues here). One idea from me first, three links that go deeper on it, then two things that have nothing to do with work. Let's get into it. 1 Idea from Me Measure the loop, not the task. The year is 1983. 45,000 American 13-year olds are given a national assessment with this question: "An army bus holds 36 soldiers. 1,128 soldiers are being bussed to their training site. How many buses are needed?" 70% did the math...